Teaching &
Learning (Indonesian Context)
Computers
Internet
 Join Our Forum
Homepages
Learning
Technology
Language
Laboratories
WW-Web Online
Teaching and Learning
Distance
Learning
Language
Learning
CALL Computer
Aided Language Learning
E-Mail Webmaster
Created April, 2000 Copyright © 2000-2008 Pendidikan
Network
|
 [
Bahasa Indonesia Di Sini
]
In our Education & Technology section it is
hoped that we can generate active participation in discussions
relating to current 'education best practices' and 'technology developments'. The primary aim
is to develop a facility that resembles a 'Laboratory for
Education Issues' and hopefully through our endeavors
(collectively) we can provide some realistic and practical
information for practitioners in the field. In this section the
focus is upon practice, and new perspectives and inputs are most
welcome. We are particularly looking for honest observations and
new ideas from the field. Join our New Education Laboratory E-Mail
Group (created 22-2-2008).
"To provide children around the world with new
opportunities to explore, experiment and express themselves." Further information.... Donate?.
 $150 Linux Mini-PC From Cina
"A Chinese company is touting an inexpensive Linux-based computer as a way to close the "digital divide." YellowSheepRiver's $150 "Municator" appears to be available now, with a three-month leadtime, suggesting it could reach market well ahead of MIT's $100 "One Laptop Per Child" (OLPC) device."
|
Much of the initial
content for this website is based upon our work and research into
education issues in Australia and Indonesia. However, it is hoped
that the information will be relevant generally, and especially for
other developing countries. We have been working mainly in the areas
of school development and education technology. We use the
example of the language laboratory below to raise some important
technology issues. Some of our recent work has caused us to
seriously question the role and effectiveness of education
technology. Is education technology important, how can we
know?.
This question has actually bothered us since
our initial research into Language Laboratories at the Ministry of
Education, Indonesia in 1998. Despite rigorous searching, we
only managed to find relatively little evidence of 'measured
benefits' for students from using the technology, and this
raised a question that has intrigued us ever since, why wasn't there more data
available? |
Language laboratories have been in existence since
about 1919 (Ralph Waltz) and widely utilized in Western countries
since about 1946 (Hocking, 1967), and many companies are still
marketing language laboratories today (2008). Why does it appear
that little scientific ("measured") research has been carried out into
their effectiveness. Most of the "evidence" that we did manage to
find on the Internet back in 1998 was rhetorical, and the source of
much of this evidence was from manufacturers, technologists and
technology departments in universities or other technology-based
institutions.
However, as an education
technologist working closely with professional language teachers
since 1977, it become evident that the ability of many teachers to
maximize the technology was a serious issue. From our studies into
applications of the language laboratory we found that with groups of
more than 20 students the role of the teacher in the learning
process is greatly diminished and 'teacher monitoring' becomes
relatively ineffective. This raised the question of its
suitability for use in most public primary and secondary
schools.
Comments from native-speaker
teachers in a survey in Jakarta at a high-profile
technology-based institution in 1986 indicated that many EFL
teachers did not believe that the language laboratory was an
effective use of their students' class time. Are they
perhaps more useful for non native-speaker teachers?
Perhaps the language laboratory is more suitable for use as
a Self-Access Facility. During lunch-breaks and free
lab-times at the University of Queensland during my period there
(1988-1993) the labs were also utilized in this way. However,
this raises the question, why have a lab at all, why not just
provide individual student units?
After 89 years the
benefits (or otherwise) relating to use of language laboratories are
still open for discussion. Have language laboratories helped
generations of students, do we know? How can we know if our
modern education technologies are really effective without more
scientific 'measurement' of the benefits?
One question
that needs to be asked is "Do we want to know?"
Do institutions that have committed hundreds of thousands of dollars
for education technology really want to evaluate their
technologies, and perhaps discover that they have made a
mistake? Education is a very competitive "business", and while I
deplore the concept of education being a business, it
is. Education is one of world's biggest industries, and
continual growth is virtually guaranteed. Like any business,
competitiveness is a key issue. How can institutions be seen to
have a competitive edge? Is education technology perhaps viewed
as 'marketing leverage' by some institutions, or as an opportunity
for 'career advancement' by some teachers and academics?
My personal experience is that sometimes just
questioning the benefits of technology in education is viewed in
the same light as questioning whether the world is flat.
Why, and what are the implications for educators who are
interested in evaluating education technology?
We are based in
Jakarta, Indonesia and we are continually attempting to answer
questions about language laboratories, computer laboratories,
e-Learning, utilizing the Internet for learning and programs for use
with the technologies.
We are very pro-technology,
however, we are also striving to establish that the technologies are
benefiting our students, especially in regions where budgets are
limited or based upon international loans. The
ceaseless questioning, evaluation, analysis and critique of
education technologies are crucial good practices that benefit
everybody.
As a result of some recent analysis of
the main factors contributing to quality education (especially for
developing countries), the role and importance of education
technology has become even more of a concern over recent months.
This is because of the exceptionally high levels of hype about
the benefits of technology in education which appear to be
dominating education decision making, perhaps at the cost of
more basic issues that are proven to enhance the quality of
education. One of my more recent concerns is:
Tablet PCs Saving Time?
"We need to be relentless in measuring and
assessing the impact that technology has on education and on
academic achievement. We need evidence that
teaching and learning are improved as the result of
technology." (Ref: North Central Regional Educational
Laboratory)
Are we "relentless in measuring and assessing the
impact" of new technologies? If not, why not?
Send Us
Your Comments!
Computers and the Internet have for some time been
accepted as essential tools for both communication and business in
Indonesia. However, now, because Indonesia is in the process of
educational reform they have become an even more important
educational issue especially for the "Year 2008
Teachers" (see survey).
This is not a commercial
site and we invite all stores, businesses and companies dealing
in; computers, audio-visual equipment, learning laboratories,
Internet Service Providers (Indonesia), Internet accessories, etc.
to send information about their products via this form so
that they can be promoted to interested parties in the Indonesian
education sector. With School Based Management (SBM) schools are now
encouraged to buy locally so we would like information from all
regions in Indonesia.
Links to useful technology homepages and personal
written contributions (papers) can also be e-mailed to us for
inclusion on this site.
We are very interested in new and innovative
applications of technology to learning and teaching equipment
(audio-visual aids). So, if you are in possession of any information
that you would like to pass on please leave a message
here.
Phillip Rekdale Education & Technology
Consultant:
|